As someone who has been around the block a few times this smells a lot like someone with a grudge/ message to tell who journal shopped for a willing accomplice. The authorship informs the grunt work was by a newly minted MPH (which right there is a red flag) which was mentored by a senior author with little to no creds in this area of research.
I haven’t been around the block in the science and medicine world except for my 27 year struggle with autoimmune issues. I respect those who place the physical and mental wellbeing of the individual (and the public at large) at the top… not to get rich and not for political purposes. I understand that we have been propagandized, intentionally, for a very long time. It has been an opiate to keep us compliant rather than respected. If you love your fellow countrymen you tell them the truth and you work through the issues together… if you want to rule them and grow powerful and wealthy in the process, you lie to them. The problem now is we no longer know whom to trust… that in itself is a *win* for some who really don't care about others. There are leashes being used, who is attached to which end is the open question.
This particular publication was peer-reviewed. That means others in the field approved it for publication. I have read though a few other Hulscher publications, (the new kid) and they seem fine. As a Patent Attorney in the sciences, I have read many, many scientific publications. I know how to do that and I know what to check for. This paper is professionally
done. Hulscher has likely published many before in his career before he received his MPH (Masters in Public Health.) Why is Dr. Malone writing what he's writing? I'm not sure, so I should probably not guess or surmise.
Peer reviewed means not one damn thing today un!ess you can convince anyone that viral geneticists regularly peer review fish and game papers. Peer review today often means selected editors sending manuscripts to selected reviewers. I doubt many who cited that paper ever heard of it until it was broached by the authors in more mainstream venues. And as for a MPH it is in my experience largely held by physicians as leg up in administration with little more required of them than a course in statistics. It does not usually come with a heavy dose of science but rather more in public health admin.
Like I said to you on X, M. Yeadon was making similar statements and you challenged him and the response was nasty. These assertions must make you want to scream after all the research and education you have provided in a scientific manner and then to be questioned about your accuracy!
Exactly, but McCulloch does this why?? A silly sort of notoriety? Money? Given what has been done, it seems a doctor with his alleged creds would naturally rise above such things - becoming a voice in our wilderness, not a shill.
Thanks for your continued help separating the "wheat" of accurate information and analysis from all the "chaff" of misinformation and outright lies that make up what seems to be a majority of the information out in the public sector. I hope you and your family have a very prosperous and beneficial New Year.
Dr. Malone I just deleted that particular email without reading before I read through your post to see your take on it. I will have to go back and read again or I think I get it just by scanning through yours. Thank you!
Malone, you should be happy, proud, and resolute in your publishing of this article. It’s nothing compared to what you’ll do in the days and weeks to come. I pay $5.00 a month to intellectually rub up against your million $$ education and experience. Think of what it’s cost you in every way. Just keep writing and we’ll keep reading until they turn the internet off. Lol
Dr. Malone - I know I've said this before, but when I see all the work (exhaustive amount of scientific literature) you comb through- to put "truth" online for your readership - it's commendable Sir.
As we enter 2025, I hope the Trump appointees, (esp. MAHA), and the 3-letter agencies, finally let go of their 'god-mentality' and strong-arm mandates to twist and pervert the natural life cycles and rhythms of mankind and animal & plant life. They have reaked havoc on the big 4 we need to live: earth, air, sky, water.
You have a lot of sound understanding- esp.farming - knowing animals - how dependant we are on having limits to what govt can force us to do - and not do. Voices like yours are needed - esp. in a new administration.
It's so clear to anyone not already brainwashed or beguiled by pseudo-science or media-babble, that if let well-enough alone, the Creators blueprint in all ecosystems and biology worked just fine for millenia- till man and the science-gods screwed it all up. It all worked as designed in mutual harmony - until the "I am science" cash-cow soothsayers poked their sticky fingers into it.
The climate-control-cash crazies, I think they have a God-complex (much like the elites at the 'tower-of-Babel' - Genesis 11: 1-9). Some things never change. But with one blow - God blew it (and them) all down. Boom. Many today [in science, media, tech-world, 3-letter agencies] are in for a rude awakening. Their false science been found out. Call it 'legal discovery' in the courtroom of the universe.
God is and forever will be a solo act. It's His universe - and I'm thankful He has the "eternal trademark, laboratory science, data, and patent" on all life forms, including us. Regeneration and Resurrection power is His ultimate 'thesis'. I've read the manual. 📖
The best is yet ahead. Love and hope and purpose cannot be birthed from a test tube or laboratory. It's an inside job: the DNA of all life is the human soul - put inside homosapiens by the finger of the Creator at conception. AI and the scientists who worship at its feet cannot duplicate, replicate or create divine life. (Tho - sadly, they will try - Revelation 13:15). But - like Babel, they will lose it all. Permanently. Only those who truly honor life- and the God who gives it - will live with God.
I initially skimmed through McCullough's article and was indeed taken aback at the certainty of his assertion that the virus came from the GA biolab, and wondered if he really had the goods to state this as fact. Thank you Dr. Malone for validating my hesitation. Add McCullough's continued defense of the wide use of statins, and it becomes clear that he is simply not a reliable source of information. You, on the other hand, contine to burnish your own reputation for credibility with thorough, well-thought-out analyses such as this. My deepest gratitude.
Jennifer true he doesn't say it in the paper but he DOES say it with great certainty in the interview. Here it is:
"The current strain of bird flu is a product of gain of function research done in the USDA Poultry Research Laboratory in Athens, Georgia. So it is a man made problem that, our farms are experiencing right now."
I watched that part of the interview. Please see my lengthy answer to Dr. Malone who asked if I had watched the McCullough interview. His question and my lengthy answer is located further down in these comments. Just look a lengthy answer to a Dr. Malone question. Thanks
I’m going to check the video to see what he says. If GOF on this is being done here, I'd want to know. So, I wouldn't oppose an investigation to definitely determine that. Thank you.
Dr McCullough STILL supports statins?? Too funny! I'd like to see him have a debate with Maryanne Demassi PhD. who uncovered the lies and wrought about 12 years ago.
We often hear the term, "fog of war," used to describe the situation where chaos and conflict make reported information unreliable. Now we have the "brain fog of PsyWar" where uncertainty is weaponized against the public to keep us disoriented and disorganized.
All these wisp-like, swirling narratives about the origins of bird flu have me confused, not knowing what to believe or what then to do about it. I suspect this is by design and not by accident.
Comedian Jimmy Dore, who describes himself as a former C student, profiles Dr. Leana Wen. C student or not, I think he is brilliant.
Dr. Wen, who per Wikipedia graduated summa cum laude with a Bachelor of Science in biochemistry at age 18, is a curious figure to me. It baffles me to see such a gifted, charming, smiling, charismatic person put her gifts to use in such a sinister way.
Jimmy even references Dr. Malone in this clip. The rigors in today's article are necessary. I'm also glad to laugh with a layman so firmly rooted in common sense. Posted today:
A question also becomes, why has Dr. McCullough signed on to be part of this? He was hunted, lost so much that he worked for… what connection does McCullough have with other members of The Wellness Company board like Dr. Harvey Risch? What does this mean? Lots of rabbit holes to go down, but I don’t have the energy for it all. There are serious geo-poltical games going on in the world, how do they align? I don’t have the bandwidth anymore to go into the micro… I tend to look at the macro. 'What it IS is what it DOES.’
Yeah, afraid I do. Or simply proving that physicians on the whole, well, rarely make good science. Understand he his a working physician seeing patients and a specialty to keep current in. That is full time work. So an element of dilettantism is to be expected. This in an unlikely assortment of authors submitting a paper the subject of which none are authorities to a rather unlikely journal. Doe.s not pass the nose test.
Pathogenesis wil be casually overlooked( intentionally ignored) by the MSM looking to gon up fear. Governor Gravid Nusiance is already wetting his drawers with his new gain of power
There are people who work hard and get the facts straight and there are people who don’t. Dr Malone, you work hard and check your facts, at least twice I am sure. Others are what you would call shit posters on X. I don’t follow shit posters.
Did you really need to ask? Thank you for the evidence. The truth is inconrovertable. Malace may attack it and ignorance may deried it; but in the the end, there it is.
At first glance, it seems as if the authors are trying to make a name for themselves. For what purpose is not known.
Or, are they exceptional thinkers who have hit on something?
As in all scientific questions, experts in the respective fields will need to thoroughly scrutinize the methodologies used by the authors to either confirm their findings, or disprove their theories, supported by their own true scientific findings.
I can appreciate Dr. Malone's input into this quest for truthful scientific investigations.
But, until true scientists who do the work to prove or disprove these conclusions (as opposed to those consensus-opinion pseudoscientists We the People experienced, who got the origins of, & the safety & effectiveness of the COVID-19 virus vaccines completely wrong! We the People can all be grateful to Dr. Malone for exposing these morons!). These studies will take time. So, be patient. And stay tuned to Dr. Malone who will keep We the People informed of the real scientific methods & evidence.
The problem with people making unsupported claims like this is that it delegitimizes the whole issue. The boy who cried wolf.
As someone who has been around the block a few times this smells a lot like someone with a grudge/ message to tell who journal shopped for a willing accomplice. The authorship informs the grunt work was by a newly minted MPH (which right there is a red flag) which was mentored by a senior author with little to no creds in this area of research.
I haven’t been around the block in the science and medicine world except for my 27 year struggle with autoimmune issues. I respect those who place the physical and mental wellbeing of the individual (and the public at large) at the top… not to get rich and not for political purposes. I understand that we have been propagandized, intentionally, for a very long time. It has been an opiate to keep us compliant rather than respected. If you love your fellow countrymen you tell them the truth and you work through the issues together… if you want to rule them and grow powerful and wealthy in the process, you lie to them. The problem now is we no longer know whom to trust… that in itself is a *win* for some who really don't care about others. There are leashes being used, who is attached to which end is the open question.
Dr. Seignalet put all autoimmune diseases into remission with diet,
www.seignalet-plus.com
Also, search for your "issue" + vitamin d deficiency + pubmed
…and yeah, war is hell and a dirty game.
And we the "readers" are in the massive learning curves of America life.
This is an awesome moment in history to be alive!
Welcome to The New Frontier!
"I've got a good feeing about this"! A coming alive..... in 2025!
What ‘new frontier’ would this be?
The one we wake to every single day.
A What's new about the possibility of WW3?
Even more so closer to home....
A What's new in my neighborhood?
The Biden's made a human migratory mess to clean up as a big thing.
There's a new frontier to deal with right there.
And we are in it!
And what about the prospects of further war and suffering for people across the globe and possibly here excites you?
New kid on block swings at inside fastballs?
This particular publication was peer-reviewed. That means others in the field approved it for publication. I have read though a few other Hulscher publications, (the new kid) and they seem fine. As a Patent Attorney in the sciences, I have read many, many scientific publications. I know how to do that and I know what to check for. This paper is professionally
done. Hulscher has likely published many before in his career before he received his MPH (Masters in Public Health.) Why is Dr. Malone writing what he's writing? I'm not sure, so I should probably not guess or surmise.
Peer reviewed means not one damn thing today un!ess you can convince anyone that viral geneticists regularly peer review fish and game papers. Peer review today often means selected editors sending manuscripts to selected reviewers. I doubt many who cited that paper ever heard of it until it was broached by the authors in more mainstream venues. And as for a MPH it is in my experience largely held by physicians as leg up in administration with little more required of them than a course in statistics. It does not usually come with a heavy dose of science but rather more in public health admin.
Well lets just begin this by saying East meets West...North Meets South...
That sets up a Storm we know so little about. This is an intell cyclone.
This was bound to happen, was it not? The science is being Challenged!
We are not the referee's in this game of skilled knowledge. OnlyObservers.
No creds has become a sort of legitimate niche?
Like I said to you on X, M. Yeadon was making similar statements and you challenged him and the response was nasty. These assertions must make you want to scream after all the research and education you have provided in a scientific manner and then to be questioned about your accuracy!
Didn’t say it to me - Strzok kicked me off Twitter and never let me back on. What a lizard-being.
Exactly, but McCulloch does this why?? A silly sort of notoriety? Money? Given what has been done, it seems a doctor with his alleged creds would naturally rise above such things - becoming a voice in our wilderness, not a shill.
I will say “Notoriety & Money”…!
Fall migratory routes across N. Alaska and west and mid central Canada flyway systems.
https://www.ducks.org/conservation/where-ducks-unlimited-works/western-alaska-aleutian-bering-sea-islands
https://www.stateofthebirds.org/2016/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/garcia-NOPI-720x615.jpg
These feathered birds carry more than just a few invasive things in migrations.
Thanks for your continued help separating the "wheat" of accurate information and analysis from all the "chaff" of misinformation and outright lies that make up what seems to be a majority of the information out in the public sector. I hope you and your family have a very prosperous and beneficial New Year.
thank you, Ed. I did not enjoy writing or publishing this, but it needed to be done.
Thank you—it’s best we don’t hide our heads in the sand—though it’s tempting at a time like today. We need Truth though it’s uncomfortable.
Dr. Malone I just deleted that particular email without reading before I read through your post to see your take on it. I will have to go back and read again or I think I get it just by scanning through yours. Thank you!
It’s a very good read
Malone, you should be happy, proud, and resolute in your publishing of this article. It’s nothing compared to what you’ll do in the days and weeks to come. I pay $5.00 a month to intellectually rub up against your million $$ education and experience. Think of what it’s cost you in every way. Just keep writing and we’ll keep reading until they turn the internet off. Lol
I truly appreciate your transparency and courage!
Me too! 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
And I thank you!
Dr. Malone - I know I've said this before, but when I see all the work (exhaustive amount of scientific literature) you comb through- to put "truth" online for your readership - it's commendable Sir.
As we enter 2025, I hope the Trump appointees, (esp. MAHA), and the 3-letter agencies, finally let go of their 'god-mentality' and strong-arm mandates to twist and pervert the natural life cycles and rhythms of mankind and animal & plant life. They have reaked havoc on the big 4 we need to live: earth, air, sky, water.
You have a lot of sound understanding- esp.farming - knowing animals - how dependant we are on having limits to what govt can force us to do - and not do. Voices like yours are needed - esp. in a new administration.
It's so clear to anyone not already brainwashed or beguiled by pseudo-science or media-babble, that if let well-enough alone, the Creators blueprint in all ecosystems and biology worked just fine for millenia- till man and the science-gods screwed it all up. It all worked as designed in mutual harmony - until the "I am science" cash-cow soothsayers poked their sticky fingers into it.
The climate-control-cash crazies, I think they have a God-complex (much like the elites at the 'tower-of-Babel' - Genesis 11: 1-9). Some things never change. But with one blow - God blew it (and them) all down. Boom. Many today [in science, media, tech-world, 3-letter agencies] are in for a rude awakening. Their false science been found out. Call it 'legal discovery' in the courtroom of the universe.
God is and forever will be a solo act. It's His universe - and I'm thankful He has the "eternal trademark, laboratory science, data, and patent" on all life forms, including us. Regeneration and Resurrection power is His ultimate 'thesis'. I've read the manual. 📖
The best is yet ahead. Love and hope and purpose cannot be birthed from a test tube or laboratory. It's an inside job: the DNA of all life is the human soul - put inside homosapiens by the finger of the Creator at conception. AI and the scientists who worship at its feet cannot duplicate, replicate or create divine life. (Tho - sadly, they will try - Revelation 13:15). But - like Babel, they will lose it all. Permanently. Only those who truly honor life- and the God who gives it - will live with God.
Elizabeth- His Light Beacon
I agree with you that Drm Malone combs through a great deal of scientific literature. God will show us the way.
💟✝️‼️
I initially skimmed through McCullough's article and was indeed taken aback at the certainty of his assertion that the virus came from the GA biolab, and wondered if he really had the goods to state this as fact. Thank you Dr. Malone for validating my hesitation. Add McCullough's continued defense of the wide use of statins, and it becomes clear that he is simply not a reliable source of information. You, on the other hand, contine to burnish your own reputation for credibility with thorough, well-thought-out analyses such as this. My deepest gratitude.
I read the paper. I have a Chemistry degree with biochemistry, as well as four graduate level classes in quantitative statistics.
Dr. McCullough never said, or implied, a "certainty" that Gain of Function came from the Georgia biolab.
Rather, he stated clearly this was a "possibility" and that "no causation has been shown."
Jennifer true he doesn't say it in the paper but he DOES say it with great certainty in the interview. Here it is:
"The current strain of bird flu is a product of gain of function research done in the USDA Poultry Research Laboratory in Athens, Georgia. So it is a man made problem that, our farms are experiencing right now."
I watched that part of the interview. Please see my lengthy answer to Dr. Malone who asked if I had watched the McCullough interview. His question and my lengthy answer is located further down in these comments. Just look a lengthy answer to a Dr. Malone question. Thanks
I’m going to check the video to see what he says. If GOF on this is being done here, I'd want to know. So, I wouldn't oppose an investigation to definitely determine that. Thank you.
Thank you for the information. Let me check the interview.
Dr McCullough STILL supports statins?? Too funny! I'd like to see him have a debate with Maryanne Demassi PhD. who uncovered the lies and wrought about 12 years ago.
All of this is so over my head, but when it comes to the things of this nature, it will always be you that I listen to and place my trust in.
We often hear the term, "fog of war," used to describe the situation where chaos and conflict make reported information unreliable. Now we have the "brain fog of PsyWar" where uncertainty is weaponized against the public to keep us disoriented and disorganized.
All these wisp-like, swirling narratives about the origins of bird flu have me confused, not knowing what to believe or what then to do about it. I suspect this is by design and not by accident.
^^Like^^
"Time to Freak Out About Bird Flu"
Comedian Jimmy Dore, who describes himself as a former C student, profiles Dr. Leana Wen. C student or not, I think he is brilliant.
Dr. Wen, who per Wikipedia graduated summa cum laude with a Bachelor of Science in biochemistry at age 18, is a curious figure to me. It baffles me to see such a gifted, charming, smiling, charismatic person put her gifts to use in such a sinister way.
Jimmy even references Dr. Malone in this clip. The rigors in today's article are necessary. I'm also glad to laugh with a layman so firmly rooted in common sense. Posted today:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwxmklUWL_M
I love his stuff
If true, this is criminal, especially if it decreases our food supply. America has an autoimmune disease, and destroying itself from within.
John Leake, one of the authors of the McCullough paper, agrees with you and states in the paper that a criminal investigation should take place.
A question also becomes, why has Dr. McCullough signed on to be part of this? He was hunted, lost so much that he worked for… what connection does McCullough have with other members of The Wellness Company board like Dr. Harvey Risch? What does this mean? Lots of rabbit holes to go down, but I don’t have the energy for it all. There are serious geo-poltical games going on in the world, how do they align? I don’t have the bandwidth anymore to go into the micro… I tend to look at the macro. 'What it IS is what it DOES.’
Fame (notoriety) corrupts?
Or a need to have a means of income.
Which is guaranteed by those 2 letters. Does not need to cheat.
Yes… but he and others were hunted down for making waves.
Do you really think he's cheating?
Yeah, afraid I do. Or simply proving that physicians on the whole, well, rarely make good science. Understand he his a working physician seeing patients and a specialty to keep current in. That is full time work. So an element of dilettantism is to be expected. This in an unlikely assortment of authors submitting a paper the subject of which none are authorities to a rather unlikely journal. Doe.s not pass the nose test.
I hear your concerns, but it doesn't appear that you have actually studied the statistics of the McCullough paper, as Dr. Malone suggested.
I am not questioning Dr. Malone… I am wondering what is going on in the bigger picture.
I hear you.
Pathogenesis wil be casually overlooked( intentionally ignored) by the MSM looking to gon up fear. Governor Gravid Nusiance is already wetting his drawers with his new gain of power
Who cares abut the bird flu or any other flu?
No-one with a serum vitamin d level of 60 ng/ml or more of vitamin d is going to be infected.
The quacks have to scare use with their nonesense so they can prey on us. They lie about sun exposure, tanning bed exposure and vitamiin d.
https://www.seignalet-plus.com/recipes/the-medical-profession-is-lying-to-us/
If you are infected, high dose vitamin c, quercetin and zinc with added copper will soon take. care of it.
https://www.seignalet-plus.com/vitamin-c-the-lazarus-vitamin/
I’m at the point where I trash all emails or anything else that has the word WELLNESS in the title.
Sharon, I believe you are correct to do so!
There are people who work hard and get the facts straight and there are people who don’t. Dr Malone, you work hard and check your facts, at least twice I am sure. Others are what you would call shit posters on X. I don’t follow shit posters.
Did you really need to ask? Thank you for the evidence. The truth is inconrovertable. Malace may attack it and ignorance may deried it; but in the the end, there it is.
At first glance, it seems as if the authors are trying to make a name for themselves. For what purpose is not known.
Or, are they exceptional thinkers who have hit on something?
As in all scientific questions, experts in the respective fields will need to thoroughly scrutinize the methodologies used by the authors to either confirm their findings, or disprove their theories, supported by their own true scientific findings.
I can appreciate Dr. Malone's input into this quest for truthful scientific investigations.
But, until true scientists who do the work to prove or disprove these conclusions (as opposed to those consensus-opinion pseudoscientists We the People experienced, who got the origins of, & the safety & effectiveness of the COVID-19 virus vaccines completely wrong! We the People can all be grateful to Dr. Malone for exposing these morons!). These studies will take time. So, be patient. And stay tuned to Dr. Malone who will keep We the People informed of the real scientific methods & evidence.
Good, useful article. Thanks for the education.
I studied the McCullough paper and its statistics. I don't get the impression that you did that, but I could be incorrect.